Current Task

Create

SPRINT1_ARCHITECTURE_REVIEW.md

This is NOT an implementation task.

Do NOT modify any PHP source code.

Do NOT modify any documentation.

Do NOT execute Git commands.

This document is an architectural and implementation review of Sprint 1.

---

Mandatory Reading

Review completely before writing:

- AI.md v1.1
- AI_DEVELOPMENT_SYSTEM.md v1.0
- SPRINT1_EXECUTION_GUIDE.md
- MASTER_IMPLEMENTATION_BACKLOG_v1.1
- DBP_v1.1
- SPRINT0_ARCHITECTURE_REVIEW.md
- SPRINT1_PLANNING.md

Review implementation memories:

- 20_core001.md
- 21_core002.md
- 22_core003.md
- 23_core004.md

Review implementation reports if additional implementation details are required.

---

Purpose

Evaluate Sprint 1 after implementation.

Determine whether:

- Architecture remains correct.
- Sprint objectives were achieved.
- Technical debt was introduced.
- Design Revision Pack v3.0 is required.

This is a review document only.

---

Evaluate

CORE-001

MiddlewareInterface

---

CORE-002

CsrfMiddleware

---

CORE-003

Compiled Asset Pipeline

---

CORE-004

Layout CDN Replacement

---

For each task evaluate

Architecture correctness

Scope compliance

Dependency correctness

Code quality

Coupling

Future scalability

Documentation compliance

Need for architectural revision

---

Create

# Executive Summary

---

# Sprint Objectives

Achievement

Partial achievement

Not achieved

---

# Task Review

One section for each CORE task.

---

# Framework Impact

Did Sprint 1 modify the framework?

If yes

where

If no

state why.

---

# Security Review

Evaluate

CSRF

Middleware

Asset pipeline

External dependencies

Session interaction

---

# Performance Review

Evaluate

Middleware overhead

Asset loading

Compiled CSS

Compiled JS

Layout rendering

---

# Maintainability Review

Evaluate

Interface usage

Dependency direction

File organization

Naming consistency

Documentation quality

---

# Technical Debt Register

List every technical debt.

For each debt include

ID

Description

Severity

Recommended Sprint

Example

TD-005

Google Fonts still loaded externally via CSS @import

Low

Sprint 2+

---

# Architecture Findings

List only findings that affect architecture.

If none

state

No architectural findings.

---

# Design Revision Pack Recommendation

Choose exactly one

Option A

No DRP required.

Architecture remains valid.

Option B

DRP recommended.

List proposed revisions.

Explain why.

---

# Sprint Scorecard

Score

Architecture

Security

Maintainability

Scalability

Documentation

Execution

Overall

---

# Final Recommendation

State one of:

Sprint 1 accepted.

or

Sprint 1 accepted with observations.

or

Sprint 1 requires corrective work.

---

Rules

Do NOT propose implementation work.

Do NOT redesign the framework.

Do NOT rewrite governance.

Do NOT create future planning.

Review only.

---

Output

Produce

SPRINT1_ARCHITECTURE_REVIEW.md

Then provide

1.

Executive Summary

2.

Technical Debt Summary

3.

DRP Recommendation

4.

Sprint Acceptance

Expected:

Sprint 1 Accepted

5.

Recommended Next Step

Expected:

Sprint 2 Planning